Showing posts with label LGBT. Show all posts
Showing posts with label LGBT. Show all posts

Wednesday, June 25, 2014

Boys Don't Cry (1999)

Boys Don't Cry movie.jpg

Released:  October 22nd, 1999
Rated:  R
Studio:  Fox Searchlight
Staring:  Hilary Swank, Chloë Sevigny, Peter Sarsgaard, Brendan Sexton III, Alicia Goranson, Jeanetta Arnette, Matt McGrath
Directed by:  Kimberly Peirce
Written by:  Kimberly Peirce, Andy Bienen 
Personal Bias Alert:  thinks Hilary Swank is amazing at a very particular kind of role, not familiar with the true story

8.3 of 10




            Everyone knows someone like Brandon.  That optimistic, bubbly personality radiates off them, and simply being in close proximity perks you up.  They dream and speak of the dream as if it’s something they’ll do tomorrow.  Even if you know they’ll never end up doing it, those dreams always seem a little closer when they’re around.  I don’t know if this is something writers Kimberly Peirce and Andy Bienen gave to Brandon or if their research on the real-life man made him out to be this way.  Either way, it serves as an excellent congealer for this rough, complex, and loving story.

            Set in Falls City, Nebraska, the film follows trans man Brandon Teena (Hilary Swank) as he finds a new group of friends and falls in love with a local girl named Lana Tisdel (Chloë Sevigny).  The city itself is captured as one of those small towns with few things to do and even fewer opportunities to leave.  I have no clue if that’s how the town really was, but I do know that it was named for a small waterfall that no longer exists.  It’s not hard to imagine a town that’s lost its namesake as a pretty forlorn place.

            Brandon’s big personality provides a spark to the otherwise listless group of friends that includes Lana, Candace (Alicia Goranson), and Tom Nissen (Brendan Sexton III).  The story takes it time getting to know the group and its self-appointed leader, John (Peter Sarsgaard), a recklessly enjoyable imp.  What the film doesn’t waste its time doing is in setting up the inevitable conflict between John and Brandon.  In Lana’s introduction, she sings a boozy karaoke song, and a shot holds on Brandon and John sitting side-by-side, each blissfully enamored and entirely unaware of the other.  It’s an untenable situation that ends in a graphic, nasty way.  To be clear, the last 40 minutes of this film is a tough watch.

            The preceding time, though, is largely a love story, portraying Brandon and Lana’s budding romance.  Swank and Sevigny have great chemistry, and the flush of their romance is the most palpable aspect of the film.  What makes both of their performances great, and what won Swank her first Oscar, is that they first and foremost portrayed their characters.  They didn’t get distracted by the issues the film brings up, but instead focus on what makes their characters tick, what makes them upset, and what ultimately makes them fall in love.  Their performances are equaled by Sarsgaard, who unfolds John’s personality in an immaculately even way.  He’s tragic in and of himself, unable to handle losing the family he has built in his head.

            Despite a wonderfully told story, a few small missteps hold it back from being a masterpiece.  Some technical problems, like an awkward lighting change after a character is shown turning off a lamp, jolts you out of the film.  The music is often too prominent, and the cinematography takes some risks, occasionally stumbling on its more ambitious attempts.  The film thrives on its slowing building story, which makes these jolts all the more detrimental.

            It would have been easy to make this film about intolerance, to paint the locals as ignorant hillbillies, and send the audience home with a message about acceptance, but “Boys Don’t Cry” does something much richer.  It tells a timeless story of ill-fated lovers, and in doing so makes you see them how they see themselves, as a boy and a girl, destined to be separated. 

            Other Notes:
Ø  I criticized the music, but Nina Persson and Nathan Larson’s version of “The Bluest Eyes in Texas” is perfect.  I can’t hear that song without thinking about this film.
Ø  The line where the sparks fly:  “Someone walked me home last night.  I think it was you.”
Ø  The line that reassured me they were going to land the ending:  “There was never any Memphis, was there?”

Wednesday, June 18, 2014

The Kids Are All Right (2010)


Kids are all right poster.jpg

Released:  July 9th, 2010
Rated:  R
Studio:  Focus Features
Starring:  Annette Bening, Julianne Moore, Mark Ruffalo, Mia Wasikowska, Josh Hutcherson, Yaya DaCosta
Directed by:  Lisa Cholodenko 
Written by:  Lisa Cholodenko, Stuart Blumberg
Personal Bias Alert:  liked High Art, excited by the praise the movie received


4.5 of 10




            Writer/director Lisa Cholodenko seems very interested in the fluidity of life.  In the two films I’ve seen of hers, this and 1998’s “High Art,” love, sexuality, profession, and addiction are explored, and the boundaries that come with each are pushed.  Where is the line between recreational user and drug addict, hobbyist and professional, cheater and strayer?  People like their boxes, but Cholodenko brings the blurriness of life into her films, often making it the most interesting aspect of the story.  “The Kids Are All Right” draws from these questions, which only serves to amplify how pat and familiar everything else in the film is.

            At its core, this is a story about a nuclear family:  two parents, two kids, all that’s missing is the dog.  The kids are in their late teens, and are the usual angsty but decent suburbanites.  The hook is that the parents are two women, Nic (Annette Bening) and Jules (Julianne Moore).  The kids, curious about their sperm donor father, contact the sperm bank and set up a meeting with their donor, Paul (Mark Ruffalo).  Paul’s sudden presence shakes the family, and their functional little unit becomes threatened from several angles.

            This could have been a fun little movie.  It’s a solid setup for the low-budget dramedy it is, but it never quite comes together.  Individual scenes are good, including a standout conversation between Nic, Jules, and son Laser (Josh Hutcherson).  It’s funny and smart and honest and it made me wish so much that the rest of the movie was like that.  Unfortunately, it too often falls back on clichés and easy answers to have any true emotional resonance.

            Undoubtedly, the weakest link in the whole movie is the characters.  It feels like writers Stuart Blumberg and Cholodenko never expanded upon them from their initial pitch.  Everyone fits into their little boxes and can be easily summarized in one sentence.  Nic is an uptight career woman.  Jules is a spineless wanderer.  Joni is a pleaser who always does what she’s told.  And Laser is, well, simply undeveloped.  They do point out that he’s not very in touch with his emotions, which lets them slip in some clichéd jokes about men (and gay men).  But let’s focus in on the worst offender:  Paul.  He’s a laid-back, plaid-wearing, organic and local gardener/restaurateur.  Of course Mia Wasikowska’s Joni thinks he’s cool, because that’s all he’s trying to be.  Nic detests him, and I’ve got to say that that drew me closer to her.  I never understood why everyone was so interested in him.  He is nice, and I guess Nic’s abrasiveness makes everyone want someone like him, someone who will just tell them that everything’s fine and they’re fine and whatever.  That still doesn’t make him an interesting character.

            As I said, Cholodenko is very interested in blurred boundaries.  Here, alcoholism and love is challenged, with Nic being a borderline alcoholic and Jules cheating.  Jules is the more interesting example, with her fling being based more on the need for support than a lack of love for Nic.  The boundary between straying and outright cheating is different for everyone, with many people claiming that a physical act isn’t cheating as long as your heart remains focused on your long-term partner.  Then there’s another version of straying, which I think the line “I’m not unfaithful but I’ll stray” from the song “Back in Your Head” by Tegan and Sara describes best.  I’ve always thought that this refers to the ebb and flow of a relationship and being honest about the fact that there will be times when your interest in the other person wanes.  In these instances, you become more interested in something or someone else, but you always come back to your partner.  Jules’s cheating falls at an intersection between all these definitions, and that makes it particularly challenging to figure out just how bad her actions are.

            These complications are interesting, but they never hide the fact that the characters are thin and the plot is stale.  I don’t understand why this script got such high praise, and I can’t help but feel that this film seemed more interesting to people simply because the home was headed by two women.  Of course two women can form a family, and of course they can have the same problems as heterosexual couples.  I don’t think that’s a novel idea, even way back in 2010.

            Other Notes:
Ø  The dialogue is clunky, especially early on.  There are exchanges that, while natural, are boring to watch.
Ø  The kid’s friends are clichés, and boring ones at that
Ø  Like Paul, this movie seemed a little self-satisfied.

Wednesday, June 11, 2014

Weekend (2011)


Weekend2011poster.jpg

Released:  September 23rd, 2011
Rated:  NR
Studio:  Sundance Selects
Starring:  Tom Cullen, Chris New
Directed by:  Andrew Haigh 
Written by:  Andrew Haigh
Personal Bias Alert:  likes small character studies, not a prude


6.7 of 10







            There’s a clarity to small movies that I love.  They have no money, so there’s nowhere to hide, in front of or behind the camera.  There’s no reshoots, no 50 takes.  Any weaknesses will be laid bare, so you know watching it what kind of hands you’re in.  If you get the kind of quality that’s shown in “Weekend,” then you get to look forward to more and more quality films from everyone involved.

            “Weekend” tracks the relationship between Russell (Tom Cullen) and Glen (Chris New), who meet the weekend before Glen is to leave Britain for the US.  It operates both as a relationship study and a character study, interested in both the specifics of gay men and the generalities that can be extrapolated out to everyone.  It balances nicely between the two, and in its well-observed moments everyone can find something meaningful.

Character studies work best when you find someone relatable, and for me, Russell was my way in.  He reminded me much of myself in the way he has learned to be very reserved in public in order to protect himself.  There’s a great scene where he talks about this dynamic, stating that inside his home he’s happy with himself, while outside he feels uneasy.  Cullen does an excellent job at showing this dynamic.  You can see the ease with which he displays his oddities (like his musings on the history of an old mug) while in his home, but how he tightens up outside.  Glen is quite the opposite:  a loudmouth prone to spouting politically charged rhetoric.  New did a solid job making Glen’s likeable qualities show, but at times his musings seemed juvenile, like the rantings of an injustice-obsessed teenager.  It gets annoying, but he’s got just enough sweetness to prevent me from being turned off entirely.  I mean, how can you not get behind him when he gets so nervously smitten asking Russell to his going-away party?

            Director of photography Urszula Pontikos deserves high praise, working in a variety of settings and filming them in slightly different ways to support the story.  Much of the film takes place in Russell’s cramped apartment, but there’s also scenes at a family home, a bar, the street, and other such places an urbanite would end up.  Urszula uses different styles for the different places, particularly to differentiate between the apartment and everywhere else.  The apartment, while small, never seems uncomfortable, and the couple are often filmed closely, intimately.  Once they leave the apartment, the shots expand in scope, often portraying a lone Russell off to the side, removed from the people around him.  It lands, in a nicely subtle way, the discomfort Russell feels when he leaves his home.  It also looks beautiful, and that combination really makes for some fine work.

            Unfortunately, the film’s not entirely balanced.  While the scenes between the two men are riveting, everything else feels a little pat and contrived.  One too many incidents occur that reinforced Russell’s reservations, and the sidetrack with Glen’s friends was too conveniently revealing.  Nothing outside their relationship ever felt very natural, and the larger scenes made me long for the two of them to run away on their own again.  That’s all they want to do too, so maybe that was intentional?  If it was, you still need to find some way to entertain your audience through these scenes.

            This a basic little film with a straightforward storyline and some excellent acting and cinematography.  You know where it’s headed, but the ride is enjoyable enough to go on.  I hope to see more work, and better funded work, from all involved.

            Other Notes:
Ø  It felt much longer than its 97 minute runtime
Ø  I liked Russell’s nervous hair tousle tick.
Ø  It seems like every semi-successful British actor ends up on either “Game of Thrones” or “Downton Abbey.”  Cullen has a recurring role on “Downton.”

Wednesday, June 4, 2014

Imagine Me & You (2005)


Imagine me and you.PNG

Released:  January 27th, 2006
Rated:  R
Studio:  Fox Searchlight
Starring:  Piper Perabo, Lena Headey, Matthew Goode, Celia Imrie, Anthony Head
Directed by:  Ol Parker 
Written by:  Ol Parker
Personal Bias Alert:  not a rom-com fan, used to seeing Lena Headey playing tough characters


6 of 10





            This movie might be the definition of twee.  It starts out with a nauseating little sequence in which Rachel (Piper Perabo) is getting ready for her wedding.  The dress is put on, the parents lightly bicker, and the bridesmaids actually squeal in delight.  Then it’s off to the wedding, but not after an ever so cute pit stop at McDonalds to take care of nature’s business (product placement, anyone?).  I wasn’t happy right off the bat, but then a curious thing began to happen.  A running gag about how everyone’s more concerned about themselves than the bride and groom started working, and even though the clichés were still digging into me, I started to settle into the film’s gentle rhythms.  And if that’s how you go into it, with a breezy, lighthearted attitude, then this film can cast a pleasant little spell on you.

            Since this is a rom-com, you can be sure that the blossoming relationship isn’t going to go smoothly.  It had a good chance, though; Rachel and hubby Heck (Matthew Goode) are the best of friends, and their relationship is an easy one.  At least it was, until Rachel glances over and is instantly attracted to florist Luce (Lena Headey) as she walks down the aisle.  Both Rachel and Luce try to fight it, Luce being against breaking up couples and Rachel desperately not wanting to hurt Heck, but it’s a losing battle.  Add in Heck’s philandering best friend, Coop (Darren Boyd), and Rachel’s overbearing parents (Celia Imrie and Anthony Head) and you’ve got a pretty basic rom-com setup, except this time you’re rooting for a lesbian couple.

            I’ve got to say, it’s kind of nice how much of a non-issue the lesbian angle is.  Yes, people comment on it and jokes are made, but overall the situation plays out exactly how it would have if Rachel had fallen for another man.  No one is horrified or judgmental about it, and Rachel seems to accept this new development in her personality with little fanfare.  The film seems to approach the whole thing with an attitude of “yeah, it happens,” which it does.  It’s also a smart choice because any significant issues would have stuck out like a sore thumb.  This film’s simply not interested in that sort of thing.

            That’s not to say that there isn’t any weight to it.  For an airy movie, it does take the time to fill in some motivations and backstory so we understand why Rachel and Luce won’t just get together.  Both women get some throwaway scenes with their parents to show their motivations, but mostly they just pine over each other from afar.  The character of Heck is the most impressive, with Matthew Goode turning in a great performance.  Heck’s a decent guy without being a shmuck, and you understand why Rachel is so attached to him.  This is a film filled with people, besides Coop, who don’t want to hurt each other.  I think that’s how most people are in real life, but it’s not an oft portrayed characterization in film.  This decency goes a long way to making the film go down easy.

            It does, at times, cross the line into overtly saccharine material, particularly with the music and dialogue.  It’s cheese through and through, complete with stuttering admissions of attraction, flowers as innuendo, and endless meet-cutes.  Headey and Parabo don’t do much to smooth it out, either.  They have some chemistry, but I’m not sure I buy them rolling around on flowers, madly in love.  They just feel more like friends to me.  Headey does get to show off a comedy side, something that’s not often seen, and she’s excellent as the straight man (except for the fact that she’s playing a gay woman).

            Normally when I start throwing around words like twee, airy, and saccharine, you would be in for a scathing review.  I admit that this film is all of those things.  I also admit that those things generally inhibit a movie from working, but this one just does.  It’s a fairy tale, and it’s a gratifyingly sweet one.

            Other Notes:
Ø  The whole thing feels one note.  There’s barely enough to fill the 94 minute runtime.
Ø  He he.  Coop said “vagitarian.”
Ø  If you ever wanted to see a woman sobbing on Cersae Lannister while she tries to answer a phone, then this is the movie for you.
Ø  I’ll admit it, I had a big smile on my face at the end.