Released: September 24th,
2010
Rated: Not Rated
Distributor: IFC Films
Starring: Nathaniel Brown, Paz de la Huerta, Cyril
Roy, Olly Alexander
Directed by: Gaspar Noé
Written by: Gaspar Noé
Personal Bias Alert: likes being challenged, wasn’t impressed by Noé’s Irreversible
3.5 of 10
Gaspar
Noé is a man that fearlessly makes films, although he probably doesn’t consider
it a fearless act. He probably wonders
why the rest of us are too meek to make these kinds of pieces, so restrained by
our quaint ideas of propriety and respect.
This openness makes him a fascinating filmmaker, but also one that’s a
bit baffling. Can you imagine creating
something as aggressively nasty as Enter
the Void or Irreversible and then
sitting in a packed theater while others watch it? Or worse, walking out onstage afterwards as
everyone is nervously fidgeting, trying to reorient themselves to the regular
world? I’ve never seen Noé in real life,
but I imagine him striding onto such a stage with an unassuming
casualness. He doesn’t expect to have to
defend his films; they’re far too meaningless to be worth a defense.
In
the few interviews I have seen of him, he seems most enthusiastic about
discussing his filming techniques, which is the one thing he undoubtedly puts a
lot of effort into. Not that his style
is any less repulsive than his content; he also pushes the boundary of making
people physically uncomfortable, forcing the audience to sit through strobing
lights and swirling frames, emphasized in Enter
the Void by the main character’s heavy drug use. In an attempt to capture the effects of such
highs, the setting disintegrates into fluid streams of glowing structures,
heavily patterned, and seemingly endless in repetition. The entire film is shot in a quite literal
first person point of view, seeing the events as the main character would and
catching glimpses of him only in mirrors and remembered flashbacks. To make things even more dizzying, he dies
towards the beginning of the film (not a spoiler) and spends most of the
runtime floating in the void of death, watching events unfold below him. The hovering effect and the blocking of the
overhead angles are thrilling if only for their uniqueness, and Noé is
attentive enough to fill the frame with a brimming, oversaturated version of
Tokyo. The visuals in Enter the Void are beyond reproach, both
for their technical and imaginative aspects, and make this film a worthwhile
study for anyone looking to explore how a camera can move.
Unfortunately,
Noé fails to bring anywhere near the same level of attention or precision to
his story. It’s a loose piece that lacks
any real sense of pace or arc, drifting (quite literally) between events that
are often so simple that it’s hard to come up with a more descriptive
term. Simply put, the film’s boring,
even when dramatic events like the main character’s death and possible
afterlife are occurring. The fact that
it’s never explicitly clear what is happening – whether we’re seeing the
character’s literal afterlife or the dying fizzles of his brain – isn’t even
enough to keep things interesting.
The
problem stems from Noé’s unrelenting tone, a mix of the-world-means-nothing
absurdism with a pessimist’s unrelenting nightmares. It’s clear that nothing good will happen in Enter the Void, and the viewer’s mind
will sense that and throw up every natural defense it has. The actors, largely inexperienced, prove
inadequate at drawing us back in, and Noé’s unoriginal shock tactics become
almost laughable. Someone unaccustomed
to the more extreme movements in European cinema may find the graphic scenes
either off-putting or revelatory, but the shock will do little to uncover any
deeper meaning. There’s simply nothing
behind this 2+ hour slog except some fancy camerawork, but perhaps that
emptiness is Noé’s preferred parting shot to his audience.
Other
Notes:
Ø Indulgent
is the best word to describe it. Or over-indulgent. Yeah, that’s a better one.
Ø That
was one of the least subtle linkings of sex and death that I’ve seen in a while.
Ø I
saw the ending coming, and I was wishing it wouldn’t make me see it. But yep, of course it made me see it.
No comments:
Post a Comment