The Hunger Games: Mockingjay - Part 1

Released:  November 21^st, 2014

Rated:  PG-13

Studio:  Lionsgate

Starring:  Jennifer Lawrence, Josh Hutcherson, Liam Hemsworth, Woody Harrelson, Donald Sutherland, Philip Seymour Hoffman, Julianne Moore, Elizabeth Banks, Sam Claflin, Jeffrey Wright

Directed by:  Francis Lawrence

Written by:  Peter Craig, Danny Strong

Personal Bias Alert:  read and liked the book, highly invested in the series’ themes

8 of 10

            I was expecting people to be disappointed by Mockingjay Part 1.  Whereas Catching Fire can be justly criticized for rehashing the same plot formula as the first film, Mockingjay goes off in an entirely different direction, abandoning many of the staples that made people love the series.  Gone are the flamboyances of the capitol, the looming authoritarianism, and, perhaps most importantly, the feeling of Katniss versus the world.

            Mockingjay finds Panem blossoming into outright revolt, with Katniss (Jennifer Lawrence) being more-or-less used by the revolution’s leaders as the symbol of their movement.  She had always been a pawn to a certain extent, a young woman playing in a world much larger than she could handle, but there had always been a sense of her making choices within that world that led to the revolution.  Now, with the reveal of Cinna’s pre-made clothing plans and Plutarch’s (Philip Seymour Hoffman) dogged insistence that she is the symbol they need, the vail has been pulled back to show how much Katniss had been manipulated and directed in the previous installments.  She’s revealed as just a girl, a hot-head with some archery skills who ended up in the right place at the right time.

            This breakdown of the character’s badassery is bound to be a letdown, especially in the middle of our current ‘chosen one’ wave where seemingly every hero has some preordained gift that allows them and only them to save the world.  What’s great about this change-up, really what’s great about what novel writer Suzanne Collins did, was that she made a revolution occur as it happens in our own world.  No magic, no cheats, just fed up people, some bombs, and lots of propaganda.

            The way in which media is used to sway the masses has been a continuous theme in the series, and it takes center stage in Mockingjay Part 1.  Being that this film only covers the first half of the book, it’s largely setup for what I imagine will be an action-packed Mockingjay Part 2.  To give this film some semblance of structure and, well, a point, writers Danny Strong and Peter Craig mine the books for their shockingly astute and dark portrait of revolutions and the people that make them happen.  They succeed wonderfully, using the extra time to finally let this film series catch its breath and really feel just how bad the world has gotten.

            Director Francis Lawrence earned the right to finish out the series after bringing great improvements to Catching Fire, and if anything he seems to have gotten more comfortable with the material.  I’ve always said that it’d be easy to make a hard R adaptation of these books, but Lionsgate wants a cash cow, so Lawrence’s great challenge is toning down the violence without losing the horror that goes along with it.  In Catching Fire he was able to lighten the tone with jokes about the capitol and the outrageous fellow tributes (especially Johanna).  He doesn’t have to be as concerned about the rating with Mockingjay Part 1 since there’s much less murder going on, and he embraced the opportunity to show the bleakness that permeates the books but was absent in previous films.  The color pallet is reduced to greys and blacks, the lighting is muted, and Katniss’s new home in District 13 is all military starkness.  Given what the series is heading for, this tonal shift is a necessary step.

            The new environment of District 13 means several new actors joined the lineup.  The respect this series has gained shows not only in the large pickups (I’m looking at you Julianne Moore) but in the swell of character actors that fill in the small parts.  Never underestimate the importance of making the small parts work.  A bad performance can grind a movie to a halt, but these people had the skill to step in and keep the whole thing moving smoothly. 

            The addition of Moore as District 13’s President Coin was bound to be a good thing, but it’s made even better when you realize that most of her screen time is spent with Hoffman.  These two have worked together on three previous films, and that familiarity and the sheer skill those two bring makes all their scenes delightful.  Unfortunately, these performance do highlight how uneven the main trio of Jennifer Lawrence, Liam Hemsworth, and Josh Hutcherson is.  I’ve always felt that Lawrence struggles with her big moments in this series, and that trend continues here.  There’s a rousing speech she’s supposed to deliver that just falls flat, especially in contrast to the evolving but effective speeches Moore delivers throughout the film.  Hemsworth finally gets to do something in this one and pulls it off extremely well, with the exception of one scene where he comes off as unnecessarily petulant.  Hutcherson gets sidelined this time around, and I think his performance would have been fine if it wasn’t hampered by some bad makeup.  Overall, the main trio still holds their own, but the rest of the cast certainly outshines them.

            I think people’s reaction to Mockingjay Part 1 is going to reveal more about what they’ve liked about the series than the actual quality of this film.  The Hunger Games has always been a well-made piece of entertainment, and Mockingjay Part 1 is no exception.  But the splitting of the last book meant that Part 1 was bound to be devoid of the intense action people have come to expect from the series, so if you’re not simultaneously invested in the characters and the series larger themes, then this one might put you to sleep.  I, for one, found these smaller moments enthralling.

            Other Notes:

Ø  The score is still a bit much.

Ø  There’s some well-handled callbacks to the previous films without being obnoxious and some decent foreshadowing of events to come.

Ø  Way to identify the building after the computers highlighted and labeled it.

Ø  I’m with Effie; jumpsuits are awful.